How to Prepare an Evidence Act Notice regarding Medical Experts and Medical Reports

When a party intends to call more than 3 experts and/or rely upon a medical report instead of calling a medical expert, an Evidence Act notice to that effect should be served.  A significant deadline to keep in mind is that expert reports are due 90 days before the pre-trial conference.

More than 3 Experts

Pursuant to section 12 of the Evidence Act, it is necessary to seek leave to call more than 3 experts.  If that is the intention, it is worthwhile to give opposing counsel a heads up.  In personal injury and medical malpractice trials, more than 3 experts is commonplace.  This is a reference to rule 53.03 experts.

Click here to purchase a template Evidence Act notice regarding calling more than 3 experts

Medical Reports

The second part of the notice indicates that pursuant to section 52 of the Evidence Act, a medical report will be relied on instead of calling the expert to testify.  It is not permissible to both call the witness to testify and file the report as well.

There are two main rationales behind giving notice in this situation.  First, filing the expert medical report may be far less costly than having the expert attend.  Second, it gives opposing a counsel a heads up that the expert is not going to be called.  Opposing counsel can summons the expert or insist they be called.  There are costs consequences if having the expert attend in person turns out to be unnecessary.

10 days notice is the minimum requirement.

Click here to purchase a template Evidence Act notice regarding filing medical reports

Medical Reports, Judges and Juries

In Jury trials where the medical expert testifies, although the report cannot be introduced as an exhibit (and won’t be in any document brief), most Judges appreciate being provided with a copy of the medical report to help them follow along with the medical expert’s testimony.  A copy should therefore be printed for the Judge.

This article is courtesy of the Ontario Civil Trial Manual

Click here for the Ontario Civil Trial Manual

Click here for our Services for Law Firms

This manual is trial information, not trial legal advice.

Copyright Notice ©

The Ontario Civil Trial Manual is copyrighted.  For permission to reproduce part of the trial manual please call (416) 944-2274 or email info@trialcounsel.ca.  Feedback and topic suggestions are welcome.  Thank you.

Hassell Trial Counsel
111 Greensides Ave
Toronto, Ontario M6G 3P8

© 2019 Hassell Trial Counsel. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use and Disclaimer